2020B08 Discuss the adverse environmental effects of anaesthetic agents in current use

 

Definitions:

Greenhouse gas

·     Substance that absorbs and emits infrared radiation

·     e.g. CO2, N2O, methane, ozone

Anthropogenic global warming

·     Warming of average temperatures on earth caused by greenhouse emissions arising from human activity

·     Many detrimental environmental effects

Ozone layer

·     O3 rich region in the stratosphere

·     Absorbs UV-B

 

List of agents:

(descending order of toxicity)

Desflurane

·     Direct AGW: 6 hours at Fi 7% ≈ 1000kmg driving

·     0.02% metabolised; also resistant to environmental breakdown

·     Greater impact mostly due to long half life

Nitrous oxide

·     Direct AGW: 6 hours at Fi 50% ≈ 500km driving

·     Depletes ozone layer

·     Chronic exposure can cause neuropathy, teratogenicity, miscarriage in health care workers due to inactivation of methionine synthetase

Sevoflurane

·     Direct AGW: 6 hours at Fi 3.5% ≈ 50km driving

·     ~5% metabolised

Propofol

·     Minimal impact on AGW, even after taking into account syringe driver, manufacture, procurement

·     Improperly discarded propofol is toxic to marine life

·     Syringes and tubing contribute to medical waste

·     Almost 100% metabolised; metabolites excreted in urine

·     Environmental effects of metabolites unknown

Ketamine

·     Minimal impact

·     Can be used as a sole agent

·     Minimal effects of ABC

·     Hence reduces need for other disposable equipment

Neuraxial/regional local anaesthetics

·     i.e. bupivacaine, ropivacaine, lignocaine

·     Minimal direct impact

·     Can be performed without sedation or general anaesthesia

·     Hence reduces need for other disposable equipment

 

 

Feedback welcome at ketaminenightmares@gmail.com